BYH Chimer Clark. Your commercial bragging about how "TOUGH AS NAILS" you are as you glower at all of us with an AR-15...

Fugitives sometimes disappear

Robert McWilliams.jpg
1 of 3
Erasmo Tamayo.jpg.jpg
Cesar Laurean.jpg.jpg

Staff Writer

Tuesday, May 15, 2018

ROCKY MOUNT — Coffee and chores: William Manning began his Saturday like any other. The Spring Hope farmer planned to cook slop for his hogs. But at 82 years old, Manning needed help with chopping and hauling firewood.

Manning spotted a young man walking along a rural road, pulled over his pickup and offered to pay him cash to help. But the man wanted the money for nothing, and he took a log from Manning's truck bed and swung it at Manning's head like a baseball bat.

A short time later a motorist found Manning's dead body laying next to his truck. That was April 25, 1970.

This is the part in the story that usually states authorities are looking for the killer.

Not this time: The murderer was arrested decades ago. Actually, he was picked up soon after Manning's body was discovered.

Robert McWilliams was stopped by a Nash County deputy walking along N.C. 58 near Denton's Store. The 22-year-old migrant farmer had Manning's wallet and $60 cash.

Convicted of robbery and second-degree murder, McWilliams was sentenced to 40 years in prison. By late 1977, he had been moved to a medium security prison in Hendersonville, where he walked away from an outside work detail.

If he's alive, McWilliams is 70. Even at that age, authorities said, he is dangerous. He has been on the lam for four decades.

Some fugitives are never found.

Erasmo Tamayo escaped from the horticulture house of a medium security prison in 1993. He was serving an 83-year sentence for second-degree murder and trafficking cocaine in the 1987 death of a cartel-connected drug supplier.

The Rocky Mount Telegram wrote about Tamayo about a decade ago. After the story was published, a federal agent contacted the paper to say Tamayo would never be found — at least in one piece. Tamayo had killed a cartel man and had to pay. Tamayo would be 58 now if he's alive, but the federal agent was pretty sure Tamayo ended up as chum for sharks in the Gulf of Mexico.

Some fugitives get pretty far, but still don't escape justice.

In 2007, U.S. Marine Cpl. Cesar Laurean had it all: A loving wife, a young child, a promising career and a mistress. But then his workplace lover got pregnant and accused him of rape. Laurean's military career was on the line. The Corps still disciplines Marines for adultery, so investigators were simply waiting for the baby to be born to conduct a DNA test. Whether the sex was forced or consensual, if Laurean was the father then he faced court martial.

But then pregnant Lance Cpl. Maria Lauterbach vanished and all of Laurean's problems disappeared along with her.

For three weeks, Lauterbach’s family couldn't convince military officials she was notAWOL. The family finally contacted the Rocky Mount Telegram. A series of stories led to national media attention as local civilian authorities closed in on Laurean as a suspect.

Worried, Laurean and his wife met with three civilian lawyers who told them he was facing the death penalty. They went home and argued. At 2 a.m. Laurean read the online version of the Telegram’s article about Lauterbach having accused a fellow — but yet unnamed Marine — of rape in the months prior to her disappearance.

The next day, authorities dug up Lauterbach’s body in Laurean's backyard. But Laurean was nowhere to be found: 20 minutes after reading the news, he left town in his pickup.

An international manhunt lasted three months before Laurean was captured in Mexico. He was down to his last peso and living off stolen avocados.

In 2010, Laurean was sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole for first-degree murder. Last year, the 31-year-old inmate was moved to a medium security prison in Tabor City.

Lindell John Kay is a reporter for The Rocky Mount Telegram.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Crime and Rescue

April 21, 2019

The following people were indicted on felony charges on April 8, 2019, by a Pitt County grand jury. All information, including addresses, is from court records:

■ Brittany Ballard, 24, 1309 Westpointe Drive, Apt. 2, possess stolen firearm for May 30, 2017, offense.

■ Terrance Leon Best, 33, 100…

April 21, 2019

A Greenville woman charged with driving while impaired was found asleep at a stoplight, according to Pitt County Court records.

Amber Leigh Baker, 20, of 4280 Stantonsburg Road, was stopped at 1:55 a.m. on April 13 near Farmville Boulevard by the State Highway Patrol. 

According to the report,…


April 18, 2019

A door was forcibly broken down to gain entry to a home during an armed robbery reported on Tuesday, according to a case report released by the Greenville Police Department.

The incident took place about 4 a.m. on April 16 on the 500 block of Spring Forest Road.

The door of the home sustained $300…

April 17, 2019

Nearly $600 in Nintendo merchandise was stolen during a home break-in reported on Monday, according to a case report released by the Greenville Police Department.

The incident took place between 10 a.m. on March 1 and 3 p.m. on April 14 on the 600 block of Cotanche Street.

The home was entered…

April 16, 2019

Two men wanted in connection to a home invasion and shooting that injured two people last month have been arrested, Greenville police said.  

Lydell Maurice Carter, Jr.,18,  of 502 N. Maple St. Ahoskie, and Iwanniza Love, 17, of 103 Ford St., Greenville each are charged with two…


April 16, 2019

When calling for help in an emergency, most people’s first contact is not with a police officer or firefighter. That calm, reassuring voice on the line is that of a telecommunicator.

National Public Safety Telecommunicators Week runs through Saturday and Pitt County Emergency Management…


April 15, 2019

Connecting former criminals with affordable housing and job opportunities is one way to keep them from winding up back in jail, officials said during a police relations committee meeting last week.

Greenville Police officer Lt. K.Z. Thomas said during Tuesday’s meeting that she sees a lot of…


April 14, 2019

Pitt County Sheriff’s Office deputies arrested a man following an investigation that tied him to several recent break-ins, including an attempt at the Hustle Mart in Farmville.  

According to a news release issued Sunday morning, deputies arrested Hiakeem J’Von Powell…


April 14, 2019

A car crash in South Carolina on Friday killed two East Carolina University students along with the driver of another car and seriously injured two more students, officials said Saturday.

Shea Crothers, 22, of 17 Avenue F, Charlotte, and James Edwin Stanley, 18, of 533 Oyster Rock Lane, Sneads…

April 14, 2019

NEW BERN — A man connected to an eastern North Carolina street gang is going to serve at least seven years in federal prison for his role in a drug conspiracy from 2012 to the summer of 2017.

Markell Wiggins, 33, of Scotland Neck, was sentenced to 86 months Wednesday in New Bern by U.S.…

251 stories in Crime and Rescue. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 26
        Next Page»   Last Page»