BYH to the one who thinks that we are energy independent because of this president. The initiatives you speak of began...

Audit reveals deficits, but no surprises in ECU athletics

1 of 3

A dump truck drives by behind Dowdy Ficklen Stadium to pick up debris due to recent renovations Friday, Dec. 22, 2017.


By Nathan Summers
The Daily Reflector

Sunday, April 15, 2018

An internal audit of East Carolina’s athletics department revealed a sports program that is more than $2.3 million in debt, but people at the forefront of the school’s finances remain optimistic about the future of its teams both financially and competitively.

The review of the school’s athletic wing was triggered by a complaint alleging misuse of funds and improper accounting. The audit finalized last week shows the Pirates went from a budget surplus of $3.5 million in 2012 to a $2.3 million deficit at the end of the 2016-17 fiscal year. It does not show any misappropriation of funds.

Rick Niswander, former vice chancellor of administration and finance, said the deficits reflect major expenses including conference entry and exit fees associated with the switch to the American Athletic Conference that soon will be paid in full. He said ECU athletics is competing in a “complex environment” on and off the field and has been taking measures to improve its financial management. He said he was not surprised by anything in the report.

“No. 1, it didn’t reveal any unaccounted-for funds or any (inappropriate) expenses or misuse of university resources,” Niswander said in an interview on Wednesday. “That’s the guts of this document. There is nothing there to many of the allegations in the complaint.”

The document shows the department overspent revenues in four of the last five fiscal years, incurring its largest deficit of $3 million in 2013-14, when it paid a $1.4 million fee to exit Conference USA. Fees to enter the AAC, expenses related to personnel changes including the firing of football coach Ruffin McNeill, a commitment to pay full cost of attendance for all student-athletes and adding a women’s lacrosse team also contributed to the deficits, according to the audit and Niswander.

The audit found the department regularly failed to achieve budget and revenue projections between fiscal year 2013-14 and 2016-17. It also found instances in which coaches and administrators in individual sports programs overspent their expense budgets, which Niswander attributed to accounting procedures that have since been addressed.

“Ticket revenue was over-budgeted for three of the four years,” the audit said. “Also, athletics has consistently not estimated enough for repairs and replacements. This category of expenses has be under-budgeted for the last three complete fiscal years.”

Repair costs largely were the result of deferred maintenance, Niswander said. Funds were not dedicated for known problems with plumbing, buildings and equipment in hopes repairs could be delayed.

Revenue streams include ticket sales, student fees, alumni support from the Pirate Club, distributions from the conference and media partners and funds from other areas such as concessions and parking. The university covers cost overruns though its State Treasurer Institutional Funds account, into which all auxiliary units including athletics, housing, dining and others contribute amounts annually. Athletics will have to repay the fund at a small interest rate of about 1 percent.

The Office of Internal Audit conducted the review after ECU alum and football season ticket holder John Bream lodged a detailed complaint in December. Niswander said the school was addressing its athletic finances before then, including instituting 10 percent spending cuts across the department.

The complaint asks not only about the use of funds to offset the athletic debt but also the transparency of the department in making numbers public. Bream questioned the decision to grant a lengthy contract extension and raise to now-departing director of athletics Jeff Compher (something the audit, by rule, does not address) and also the school’s payback strategy.

“The athletic business, like any business, goes in cycles, and they have a deficit right now,” said Niswander, himself a certified public accountant and auditor who added that ECU athletics has faced deficits in the past. “Now we’re in a down time, but if everything goes like we think it’s going to go, it’s going to come back up. This isn’t terribly unusual.”

The department last summer began implementing steps to address deficits, the audit said. In addition to the 10 percent spending cuts, which don’t include payroll, benefits and scholarships, measures include:

• Developing more realistic operating budgets and a five-year operating budget projection.

• Closer communication with the new vice chancellor for administration in finance, Sara Thorndike.

• Providing expense data to coaches, budget managers and sports administrators on a weekly basis.

• Providing training on budget-related reports and tracking tools.

• Requiring purchases greater than $250 be approved by sports administrators, not just the coaches.

The audit also reviewed questions about the $55 million southside stadium expansion. It said the university secured a $55 million line of credit from BB&T until bonds were issued this spring. The bonds will be settled with payments of about $3 million annually. The Pirate Club has provided about $6 million for a contingency fund, the audit said.

“This funding will serve as a cushion in the event that future revenue stream cannot pay the bond payments. Management’s current anticipation is that additional revenues from seat licenses, the field level club and premium parking will be sufficient to cover the bond costs,” the audit said.

The contract for construction also caps costs at $60 million. Any expense over that amount must be assumed by the contractor.

The review acknowledge a degree of risk in the endeavor and said the authority to accepts such risk rests with senior management, the ECU Board of Trustees and UNC Board of Governors.

Niswander said the decision was thoroughly researched and debated at all levels. Officials determined support from alumni and fans was sufficient to move forward, even in light of recent poor attendance and losses by the football team.

They also looked ahead to the satisfaction of conference fees and other major expenses and better financial management going forward, he said. It’s a long-range outlook, and it’s predicated on what they believe will be a more competitive football team.

“If we’re 3-9 every year, we’re going to have a challenge,” he said. “It’s a calculated judgment with a lot of thought and consideration behind it. ... Underlying all of it is the football team has to do better.”

The review was conducted by a team led by ECU auditor Stacie Tronto, and Niswander noted that such audits, even though they are internal, are independent, objective and subject to scrutiny by outside sources. He also said the university and the Pirate Club both are routinely audited by outside and state entities.

While not every claim warrants an audit, Niswander said the amount of chatter created by Bream’s complaint pushed it to that level. 

Despite the negative balance sheet, he said the good news in the audit is that it provides a detailed account of spending versus revenue by the athletic department while also answering to critics that “nothing bad is going on.”

Bobby Burns contributed to this report. Contact Nathan Summers at nsummers@reflector.com, 252-329-9595 and follow @NateSumm99 on Twitter.


Visit this story at reflector.com to read the report from ECU Office of Internal Audit.



Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.


December 16, 2018

Things only fell into place in spurts for the East Carolina women’s basketball team on Sunday afternoon, but the Pirates cashed in on those surges to upend South Carolina Upstate, 63-53 in Minges Coliseum.

The Pirates (7-2) build a big early lead but found themselves in a one-point battle by…


December 13, 2018

East Carolina’s Justice Gee dropped in a 3-pointer at the final buzzer and flexed her muscles at midcourt as not only her teammates rushed to her in celebration, but also more than 6,000 local school children in the Minges Coliseum stands shouted and cheered and danced and joined in the fun.…


December 13, 2018

East Carolina’s women’s basketball team will be looking to continue an unbeaten run in Education Day games when it hosts Liberty today at 11:30 a.m. in Minges Coliseum.

The contest will bring thousands of school children into Minges for the annual late-morning tip-off. ECU is 5-0 all-…


December 12, 2018

Dave Hart wants unity and success for East Carolina athletics as much as anyone, which is part of the reason why he is continuing in his role as special athletics adviser for ECU for another year.

Hart has been in the role since March 15, helping with a critical transition as the Pirates parted…


December 11, 2018

East Carolina basketball forward Jayden Gardner completed the final academic exam of his freshman fall semester on Tuesday, and now he can turn most of his attention to basketball, but that means more practices than games for him and the Pirates.

ECU (6-4) is near the middle of its oddest…


December 11, 2018

Two East Carolina football recruits are experiencing the unique blend of high school football glory and college football recruiting to the fullest extent this week, including the multi-talented Traveon Freshwater from Elizabeth City.

Freshwater and his teammates at Northeastern High will play in…


December 09, 2018

Jon Gilbert’s experience in athletics ranges from being an administrator at big-time Southeastern Conference schools Alabama and Tennessee to holding his first athletics director position last year at Southern Miss, a school that in many ways is similar to East Carolina and used to be a rival…


December 07, 2018

Pitt County East Carolina football recruits Jeremy Lewis of South Central and CJ Johnson of D.H. Conley doubled down on their commitments following the arrival of new head coach Mike Houston this week.

Attempts to reach Farmville Central’s Keziah Everett for comment were unsuccessful.



December 07, 2018

First-year East Carolina head football coach Mike Houston announced the addition of 10 members to his initial Pirates’ staff on Friday.

All have assumed their duties immediately.

Among the additions are eight coaches who were on Houston's staff at James Madison, five on the offensive side of…


December 07, 2018

The difference in total yards — 614 to 362 in favor of James Madison — tells a lot of the story of JMU’s 34-14 win over East Carolina at Dowdy-Ficklen Stadium to begin the 2017 season for both teams.

Coach Mike Houston, who posted a 37-6 record at JMU in three seasons before…

306 stories in ECU. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 31
        Next Page»   Last Page»