Loading...
Bless our stormwater system's heart (does it have one?). Seemed to hold up pretty well to me, Calvin. Stormwater is...

Amendment wouldn't guarantee hunting, fishing freedom

070513RiverParkNorth4_0.jpg-1

Visitors to a North Carolina park enjoy fishing on July 4 in 2013.

Loading…

Thursday, July 5, 2018

State fishing license requirements were suspended Wednesday in honor of the Fourth of July. If voters pass a constitutional amendment establishing the right to hunt and fish, could anglers enjoy the same freedom 365 days a year?

In short, probably not.

The text of Senate Bill 677, which places an amendment to the North Carolina Constitution on our ballots this November, starts out with a ringing endorsement of individual liberty.

"The right of the people to hunt, fish and harvest wildlife is a valued part of the State's heritage and shall be forever preserved for the public good," the proposed amendment states. "The people have a right, including the right to use traditional methods, to hunt, fish and harvest wildlife..."

So far, so good. But the amendment continues:

"... subject only to laws enacted by the General Assembly and rules adopted pursuant to authority granted by the General Assembly to (i) promote wildlife conservation and management and (ii) preserve the future of hunting and fishing."

Tar Heels, then, would have the right to hunt and fish — as long as the General Assembly and N.C. Wildlife Resources Commission say it's OK.

We've noted Fishing Freedom Day's sad irony in the past. The one-day reprieve from licensure requirements is meant as a symbolic nod to American freedom, but it only serves to remind us how regulated, subjugated and micromanaged we are the other 364 days of the year.

Take the kids fishing on Independence Day without the state's permission and you're fine. Plan the same outing today and you'll likely pay a fine.

There are reasons the state charges license and permit fees for hunting and fishing, of course, but are they valid ones?

Wildlife conservation is the chief excuse, and it's true that the fees sportsmen and anglers pay help the state manage populations, monitor annual takes and work to prevent extinction and overfishing — all necessary tasks. What's not clear is whether the same result could be achieved voluntarily through membership in private conservation groups also working to preserve the state's stock of seafood and wild game.

Could organizations like the U.S. Sportsmen's Alliance, International Game Fish Association, Trout Unlimited, National Wild Turkey Federation and Ducks Unlimited take care of conservation by signing up members and sponsors instead of requiring people to pay up before they're allowed to hunt and fish?

Voluntary self-regulation is preferable to government using its power to shake people down. It's nearly always just as effective.

Former state Sen. Buck Newton, R-Wilson, initially sponsored a version of the hunting and fishing amendment during his time in the legislature. Many media outlets mocked the bill as red meat, pardon the pun, for conservative voters. We countered that living off the land and feeding oneself is a natural right that ought to be enshrined in the state constitution.

The amendment's latest iteration doesn't seem to accomplish that. It seeks to call something a right but treat it as a privilege — that is, to subject it to all manner of laws, rules and regulations.

Judges used to draw a bright line between constitutional rights and conditional privileges. In the 1943 case Murdock v. Pennsylvania, the U.S. Supreme Court declared that "no state shall convert a liberty into a license and charge a fee therefore."

Murdock jurisprudence has been hollowed out by 70-plus years of conflicting case law, most notably decisions that have found significant limitations on Second Amendment rights to be constitutional.

What's interesting about the hunting and fishing amendment is that, if passed, the language of the newly recognized right would limit itself by making Tar Heels' ability to hunt and fish subject to statute and rule, both of which are subordinate to the state constitution.

The constitution is supposed to limit lawmakers' leeway, not give them unlimited discretion.

Folks can vote for the hunting and fishing amendment if it makes them feel better, but the language it contains makes the "right" to hunt and fish all but meaningless. Perhaps its Republican sponsors are more keen on big government than they're letting on, and the appeal to liberty is little more than a clever marketing trick.

The Wilson Times

Loading…

Humans of Greenville

@HumansofGville

Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Editorials

September 18, 2018 - 33 minutes ago

"The youth use of e-cigs is rising very sharply," Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Scott Gottlieb said Wednesday, as he issued the federal government's most forceful warning yet that these electronic nicotine-delivery devices are hooking a generation of teenagers. He promised that…

Flavored Vaping Sales Ban

September 17, 2018

America shouldn’t be in the coup business. Period.

It’s a relief, then, to learn that the Trump administration chose not to aid rebellious leaders in Venezuela seeking to overthrow President Nicolás Maduro. But it’s worrisome to think that President Trump and his advisers…

Venezuela Nicolas Maduro

September 14, 2018

Over the past few decades, there has been a proliferation of criminal statutes and regulations carrying criminal penalties at the federal level. As Congress debates criminal justice reform, mens rea reform should be on the table.

For years, Sen. Orrin Hatch, R-Utah, has introduced and called for…

Trump Finance-3

September 13, 2018

It is tremendously sad and horrific to think about the forthcoming disaster and what it could bring to our communities and our neighbors to the south. We did nothing, really, other than live like we always have, to bring this on ourselves. Nevertheless, it is here.

Hurricane Florence, a major storm…

091218Sandbagging-4.jpg

September 12, 2018

You can add the name Jordan McNair to the list of college, high school and middle school players who might have needlessly died for the love of football.

A simple, well-known procedure — immersing McNair, 19, in a tub of ice water — when he collapsed at an off-season University of…

082918ECUFootball-5.jpg

September 11, 2018

By now, few might lift an eyebrow at President Trump’s crusade to delegitimize his own Justice Department and, specifically, his attorney general, Jeff Sessions. It long ago became clear that Trump regards federal law enforcement — as he sees all of government — as a political…

Trump Sessions

September 08, 2018

Republican state lawmakers decided last week to investigate the Cooper administration’s slow response to Hurricane Matthew relief in some of the state’s hardest-hit areas. That could be a useful exercise, if our legislators use what they find to fix real problems, and they don’t…

090518Cooper-HilmaGreens-2

September 07, 2018

When all of the state’s living former governors, including Pat McCrory, and all of the state’s former chief justices, including arch-conservative I. Beverly Lake Jr., come out against something unanimously, chances are it’s a bad idea.

Even the General Assembly had to notice…

North Carolina Ballot Battle

September 07, 2018

If President Donald Trump hadn’t bragged at a campaign rally in Alabama that if he were an NFL owner, he would fire any “son of a bitch” who knelt during the national anthem, would Colin Kaepernick be a face of Nike’s Just Do It campaign?

Would a black-and-white image of…

Kaepernick Nike

September 06, 2018

State Treasurer Dale Folwell asked a simple question: How much should North Carolina taxpayers be shelling out for state workers to receive care at UNC Health medical facilities?

The University of North Carolina Health Care System’s answer: That’s a secret.

State employees won’t…

103 stories in Editorials. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 11
        Next Page»   Last Page»