Loading...
No BYH to Trump voters, you elected a bulldozer to our norms, institutions and very stability. and whatever happens...

Schools need rules to offer free speech guidance

Loading…

Saturday, October 13, 2018

It’s sorely tempting to criticize Harnett Central High School Principal Cindy Gordon after she reportedly kicked a student out of a football game for wearing a Donald Trump shirt. But examining this blunder in isolation misses the bigger picture.

The Oct. 5 incident didn’t happen in a vacuum. It’s just the latest example in a string of public school censorship cases in the state, and it’s ultimately education leaders and lawmakers, not error-prone principals doing their best to keep the peace, who bear responsibility.

Mike Collins told The Daily Record of Dunn that his son Matthew was wearing a replica baseball jersey with USA and the Statue of Liberty torch on the front and Trump and the number 45 on the back. Matthew Collins wore the shirt in accordance with the school’s own theme — it was “USA America Night” at the Trojans’ stadium.

Gordon approached Matthew Collins and said parents were complaining about the jersey, according to the student’s dad. She allegedly told him to leave and change shirts. The teen left and did not return. “He just went home because he was so embarrassed and he felt violated,” Mike Collins told the newspaper.

School officials are investigating, but there’s no great mystery. If the incident happened as the Collinses say, this was a crystal-clear violation of a student’s First Amendment right to free speech. No ifs, ands or buts about it. We’re not breaking any new legal ground in Harnett County. This isn’t a close call.

The family has hired an attorney. We predict this episode will end with a teachable moment for Harnett Central, and to the extent that a public apology educates the principal, parents and students about the Constitution, the net outcome will be positive. But censorship really need not occur to facilitate a lesson that should be taught in freshman civics.

Tinker v. Des Moines, the landmark 1967 Supreme Court decision affirming high school students’ right to wear black armbands in protest of the Vietnam War, is the controlling case law here. It’s a bulwark against administrators acting to stifle controversy by stamping out students’ political speech.

“It can hardly be argued that either students or teachers shed their constitutional rights to freedom of speech or expression at the schoolhouse gate,” Justice Abe Fortas wrote for the majority in the 7-2 opinion.

Public schools can curb speech that results in material interference with school functions, but it takes more than mere complaint or confrontation. As if peering into principals’ minds, Fortas helpfully clarified: “undifferentiated fear or apprehension of disturbance is not enough to overcome the right to freedom of expression.”

Harnett Central isn’t the first public school and probably won’t be the last to muzzle student speakers. A pair of North Carolina schools — Richmond Early College High School in Hamlet and Piedmont Community Charter School in Gastonia — made headlines for yearbook censorship in 2017.

In Richmond County, the principal confiscated an entire press run of yearbooks and had them destroyed due to controversial senior quotes including President Trump’s campaign rallying cry, “Build that wall!”

Principals have a difficult job keeping order on high school campuses in this day and age. If they aren’t being equipped with a working knowledge of First Amendment basics, our state is setting them up to fail. And any such failure could result in a high-dollar damage award in federal court for which we, the taxpayers, would be on the hook.

In a stinging rebuke of censorship at our state’s public universities, the General Assembly passed the Restore/Preserve Campus Free Speech Act in June 2017. The time has come for similar legislation to prevent the suppression of speech at the K-12 public school level.

Lawmakers won’t reconvene in regular session until next year. In the interim, State Superintendent Mark Johnson should issue a memorandum affirming students’ right to wear political clothing and voice their views on matters of public concern.

Administrators are flunking the free-speech test because our state’s educational bureaucracy is failing them. To support outspoken students and simultaneously stand behind their overworked teachers and principals, we must hold the legislature and N.C. Department of Public Instruction responsible for safeguarding students’ expressive rights.

The Wilson Times

Loading…

Humans of Greenville

@HumansofGville

Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Editorials

January 18, 2019

For lawmakers looking for a way to end the longest government shutdown in history, we have a suggestion. Google the 13th Amendment and read what it says. It’s just one sentence.

“Neither slavery nor involuntary servitude, except as a punishment for crime whereof the party shall have…

eleanorclift.jpg

January 18, 2019

What is among the most nagging, gear-grinding frustrations generated by the Great Government Shutdown is that the folks in Washington will do nothing about it except whine.

The shutdown will enter its 28th day today. Apparently, the impasse is over funding to build for a wall between Mexico and the…

Government Shutdown-3

January 17, 2019

UNC-Chapel Hill Chancellor Carol Folt has displayed patience and grace in navigating the various pressures from the UNC System Board of Governors and the leadership of the General Assembly. It has been particularly evident in addressing the controversy over the fate of the “Silent Sam”…

Confederate Monuments North Carolina

January 16, 2019

Two weeks into this new session of Congress and we’re no closer to knowing who will represent North Carolina’s 9th District in the House of Representatives. Nor do we know who will make the final call on how the seat will be filled or who will fill it. Will it be the state’s board…

Election 2018 9th Congressional District-2

January 14, 2019

Since 1990, lions, tigers and other big cats have killed 24 people ... in the United States.

The latest fatality occurred one week ago near Burlington, when a captive lion attacked and killed an intern at a wildlife center.

Alexandra Black, 22, who had been on the job for only two weeks, was…

Lion Attack-1

January 13, 2019

How fitting is it that President Trump’s first Oval Office address was aimed at stirring up the American public about a crisis largely of his own making?

Pursuing poorly thought-out and even more poorly executed policies on the pretext of battling a nonexistent national security crisis, Trump…

Government Shutdown Trump

January 12, 2019

A federal court ruling in Iowa could signal the unraveling of North Caroina’s harsh, punitive and shortsighted anti-whistleblower law.

The U.S. District Court for the Southern District of Iowa on Wednesday struck down that state’s ag-gag law because if violated the First Amendment. The…

January 11, 2019

When North Carolina’s Republican legislative leaders have seen their work struck down in court as unconstitutional — as they have many times — they have frequently responded by attacking the judge or judges as partisan hacks.

That approach won’t work if the conservative-…

Supreme Court Kavanaugh

January 10, 2019

Very promising news about antibiotic use in farm animals has come from the Food and Drug Administration. The problem of resistance — the tendency of bacteria to fight back against antibiotic drugs — has been growing for decades, fueled by overuse and misuse of antibiotics in human…

beef

January 09, 2019

The new session of the General Assembly that convened at noon Wednesday may hold some interesting political twists and turns. Things have changed a bit, in an important way.

As it’s been throughout this decade, Republicans are in charge. But unlike the past few sessions, they no longer hold a…

state seal
85 stories in Editorials. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 9
        Next Page»   Last Page»