BYH: To the city of Greenville. You spend dollars promoting uptown Greenville to draw many in. Now you want to drive...

Duke Energy shareholders should pay for mistakes

Duke Energy Coal Ash

Crews with Duke Energy remove coal ash from the old coal ponds at the Sutton Plant, in Wilmington, N.C. Duke Energy Corp., the country's largest electric company, was ordered Monday to excavate coal ash from all of its North Carolina power plant sites, slashing the risk of toxic chemicals leaking into water supplies but potentially adding billions of dollars to the costs consumers pay.


Sunday, April 7, 2019

If you care about safe water for all, you should be celebrating the North Carolina Department of Environmental Quality’s decision to order Duke Energy to excavate coal ash from its power plant sites in the state. It was the right call for communities that for too long have been vulnerable to the environmental impact and health threat of coal ash contamination.

But now comes the harder question: Who should pay for it?

Monday’s order, if not successfully appealed by Duke, means that the utility will have to drain all 31 of its N.C. ash ponds and excavate millions of pounds of coal ash, the Observer’s Bruce Henderson reports. Duke had proposed a less expensive option of draining and capping the ash ponds or taking a hybrid approach of removing some ash and using smaller caps. The company warns that a full excavation of the ponds will cost billions more, and it will want customers to pay the bill.

That call will be made by the seven-member N.C. Utilities Commission, which decides when and how much Duke can raise its rates. One bad sign for your electricity bill: Last year, the commission agreed with Duke that customers should pay a $546 million tab to close coal ash sites around the state. The commission did fine Duke $70 million for mismanaging coal ash, which dropped the total Duke could recoup from customers to $476 million. N.C. Attorney General Josh Stein has vowed to appeal the commission’s $546 million ruling.

Duke argued then, as it surely will argue again, that it followed industry standards in managing its coal ash ponds, and that customers should share the responsibility of Duke complying with state regulations that govern its operations. There didn’t seem to be much sharing going on last year, however, as the Utilities Commission granted Duke practically all of its request, despite staff estimating that the utility already was saving $210 million per year thanks to 2017 tax cuts from Congress and President Donald Trump.

The decision also didn’t reflect that Duke knew its handling of coal ash created a potential hazard for years. Instead of acting responsibly and doing what N.C. DEQ is requiring now, the company chose to deal with the waste in what appeared to be the cheapest way possible. That has resulted in disastrous spills and breaches and, according to one report, some of the worst ash-contaminated groundwater in the U.S. near Duke’s Allen plant on Lake Wylie. Given the years of warnings about coal ash hazards, Duke’s claims that it was merely doing what other utilities did rings hollow.

We appreciate that Duke, like any business, wants to raise prices to accommodate new expenses. The company has, for years, provided reliable electricity at a relatively low cost. But the Utilities Commission should weigh the burden rate hikes place on low-income customers, and it should consider how Duke has wasted years that could have been spent dealing with the coal ash properly. Duke’s shareholders, not its customers, should pay the price for those mistakes. At the least, the burden should be distributed more equitably.

The Charlotte Observer


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.


August 18, 2019

A nearly unanimous vote by the Greenville City Council this month to annex nearly 400 acres well outside the city limits raises questions about the rights of rural residents and the city’s direction when it comes to managing growth.

The council voted 5-1 with Rick Smiley in opposition to…


August 09, 2019

The Trump administration is considering a draft regulation to lower drug prices. North Carolinians have little reason to celebrate.

The administration’s proposal would impose price controls in Medicare. Rather than helping patients save money, this drastic step would stifle access to state-of-…

Mary Griswold.png

July 28, 2019

Everyone embroiled in the debate over the State Health Plan should be working toward the same thing: the best health care for the lowest cost for the people of North Carolina.

Unfortunately, disagreement over how to do that escalated into a feud and now has plummeted into a childlike spat.


Vidant medical center

July 21, 2019

“Send her back!”

The racist refrain, soft at first, crescendoed as the crowd at President Donald Trump’s “Keep America Great” rally on Wednesday in Greenville emphatically picked it up. On live television, sitting stage right of the President at East Carolina…


July 04, 2019

As the story goes, our Founding Fathers declared their independence from their mother country 243 years ago today, that the “united colonies are, and of right, ought to be free and Independent States; that they are absolved from all allegiance to the British Crown.”

It is a day that…

07-04-19 July 4th Flag2

June 10, 2019

As the election results became clear in 2016, financial markets rose amid a surge of economic optimism. That surge continued for two years as Donald Trump and Republicans pursued a pro-growth agenda of tax reform, deregulation and encouraging domestic energy production. But with Democrats now…

June 08, 2019

Keith Cox served the residents of Virginia Beach in the public utilities department for 12 years.

Well-liked by co-workers, he spent his final moments on Friday working to protect them from a gunman in the municipal center — sacrificing his life in the process.

The remembrance of Cox,…

APTOPIX Virginia Beach Shooting-6

June 04, 2019

Give Harry Smith credit for being willing to do his homework and change his mind.

Smith, the usually outspoken and politically conservative chairman of the University of North Carolina Board of Governors, emerged from a recent board meeting and told reporters that his thinking about what to do…

Confederate Monuments-5

June 03, 2019

Vice President Mike Pence came to Charlotte this week for a 2020 Republican National Convention kickoff event. The visit was a reminder of the discomfort many feel in this progressive city about the 2020 RNC — an uneasiness so deep that Mayor Vi Lyles said last summer that she wouldn’t…

RNC Charlotte 2020-4

June 01, 2019

A state budget is a spending plan, but the proposal the state Senate’s Republican majority presented Tuesday is better described as an anti-spending plan. It is an unalloyed version of Senate leader Phil Berger’s iron-rule of government: Cut taxes and spend the absolute minimum. If…

State Of The State North Carolina-3
26 stories in Editorials. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 3
        Next Page»   Last Page»