Bless our stormwater system's heart (does it have one?). Seemed to hold up pretty well to me, Calvin. Stormwater is...

The Seahorse: Home of daddy's steaks and mama's cakes

1 of 2

Four-layer, old-fashioned chocolate cake.


Christina Ruotolo

Wednesday, July 11, 2018

The smell and taste of food can catapult us back to our childhood, to a time when trips to family restaurants were weekly affairs, everyone knew our name, what our favorite drink was and how we liked our steak. The best part was the gleaming, rotating dessert wheel that was filled with every flavor of cake, pie and cobbler. It was overflowing with sugar and sweetness just like Grandma made. If you are looking for this same nostalgia, then head over to the Seahorse Restaurant, 2301 Stantonsburg Road.

It’s no surprise that the Seahorse Restaurant has built quite a following since opening almost eight years ago. The nostalgic breakfast menu features homemade sausage and cheese biscuits, and a daily lunch buffet includes some of the best comfort food around. But both are exceeded by the incredible nightly made-to-order steak and seafood offerings, complemented by the delicious, homemade cakes.

Owner Danny Smith is proud that his restaurant has a loyal group of patrons and is known for its courteous staff. He is committed to his customers’ overall experience from beginning to end.

“We invest in our employees and customers,” he said, “and have a commitment to quality, a desire to build relationships with our customers, thus giving them a rewarding experience.”

This is evident in the steaks. Seahorse is known for “Daddy’s Steak,” and Smith is a type of steak whisperer. So it was no surprise that, for my food tasting, I started with the main attraction, the beef!

The Seahorse serves USDA prime Black Angus rib eyes. Smith has a dedicated aging system that allows him to dry age thenbeef (on average 45 days). This process yields steaks that are more tender and flavorful. The Seahorse also offers filet mignon and a flat-iron steak for those who prefer leaner meat.

Every Saturday night, the Seahorse features “One-of-a-Kind Prime Rib Roast.” The loins are coated with Smith’s secret rub, which is more of a flavorful paste, a cross between a wet marinade and dry rub made with lots of garlic, olive oil, salt, pepper and some additional secret ingredients. The steak is seasoned, rested for days, then slow-cooked for 24 hours, never getting above 135 degrees. The result is prime rib that is truly fork tender. You can get two 8-ounce cuts for $34.99. Bigger cuts also are available.

The Friday Night Feature is Chateaubriand (beef tenderloin cooked just like prime rib). It’s an item usually offered at big-city, high-end steak houses. But at the Seahorse, it’s definitely a bargain. A 6-ounce cut is $19.99, and the 8-ounce cut is $25.99.

My 12-ounce rib eye came out on a sizzling iron skillet with a little pool of juices on top and steam rising from its medium-cooked belly. The aroma itself was incredible. It was juicy and tender with a deep flavor profile. The 8-ounce rib eye is $18.49, and the 12-ounce is $22.49.

Now that your mouth is watering for steak, let’s move onto to delectable desserts that will make your tongue swoon. Kathy Smith has been baking mile-high cakes and desserts for many years and cooks the way Grandma does with a dash of sugar, spice and everything nice. The cakes come in either two-layer or four-layer in a multitude of flavors including strawberry, lemon, HoHo, Hershey bar, pineapple, coconut, old-fashioned chocolate and butter pecan. They are so popular that the restaurant goes through an average of 140 cakes per week.

I sampled the four-layer, old-fashioned chocolate cake. The buttery, yellow cake was moist and dense at the same time. The thick, decadent frosting that was cooked on the stove using butter, cream, cocoa, powdered sugar and pecans, so it had that thick, fudge-like consistency and melted on my tongue. With a dedicated baker in-house, cakes are baked daily, so you will always get a fresh, moist slice or full cake for your next party or event. Full two-layer cakes are $18.99, and four-layer cakes (10-12 slices each) are $36.99. Single slices cost $4.49. No matter how you slice the cake, it’s delicious.

The Seahorse also offers a lunch buffet Tuesday-Sunday. The menu changes a little each day, but always features items such as fried chicken, hamburger steak and home-cooked vegetables. Thursday features chicken pastry and country-style fried squash. Sunday is the grand buffet: shrimp, oysters, flounder, fried chicken, hamburger steak, baby-back ribs, chicken pastry and lots of vegetables. On Sundays, the cake comes with the buffet. You can view the daily buffet menus on the Seahorse website. The price for one trip to the buffet is $9.49 Tuesday-Saturday, or enjoy the all-you-can-eat-buffet for $12.49. Buffet prices include beverages. The lunch buffet is served from 11 a.m.-2 p.m. Tuesday-Saturday and 11 a.m.-3 p.m. Sunday. The buffet on Sunday is all you can eat for $13.99.

Seahorse offers a breakfast buffet from 8-10 a.m. Saturdays. Enjoy breakfast favorites like scrambled eggs, homemade cheese biscuits, homemade hash browns, high-end breads, homemade sausage gravy, sausage and thick-cut bacon. Price is $8.99 for adults, $5.99 for kids 5-10 or $2.99 for kids 4 and younger.

The Seahorse is open from 7:30 a.m.-9:30 p.m. Tuesdays-Saturdays and 7:30 a.m.-3 p.m. Sundays. Catering is available. For more information or to place an order for cakes or catering, call 758-6958 or visit www.the seahorserestaurant.com.

Ice Cream Festival

Simply Natural Creamery, 1265 Carson Edwards Road, Ayden, will host an Ice Cream Festival from 10 a.m.-7 p.m. Saturday.

The event will include wagon ride tours, food vendors, pony rides, mini train rides, face painting, crafts and a classic car ride in. The event will include a food drive being held in partnership with Hope of Glory Ministries. People donating selected items for Hope of Glory’s food co-op program will receive a discount on their ice cream purchase. Call 746-3334 or visit simplynaturalcreamery.com. Visit hope-of-glory.org for a list of food items needed.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.


September 16, 2018

It should come as no surprise that Pitt Community College found its new president, Lawrence Rouse, just 63 miles down the road in Kenansville.

Rouse is a native of Sumpter, South Carolina, but he spent 13 years in Duplin County as president and CEO of James Sprunt Community College.


Bob Garner

September 16, 2018

How did Carrboro writer and teacher Georgann Eubanks become the leader of the North Carolina Literary and Historical Association?

In a word, she earned a top role in our state’s cultural community by her diligent and unselfish community service that has made things better for all of us. For…


September 16, 2018

Q I am reading your book “The Well-Behaved Child” and have a question that it doesn’t address. I am a single mom with children from two different fathers. One of my ex-husbands (my son’s father) and I have arranged to do regular “child-exchanges.” One weekend,…


September 16, 2018

Q I have been married to my second husband for 24 years. We have a 16-year-old and I have two adult children.

I have moved seven times in 17 years for his job. He didn’t have to quit and take another job, but they were opportunities for him to climb the ladder in his career. I have had to…

Carolyn Hax

September 16, 2018


Dear Short Answers:

I have a wonderful family with three kids, five grandkids and a terrific husband. I’m not sorry about any of the decisions that I made, but I am feeling more and more like I didn’t fully explore the alternatives that seem to be available to…

Short Answers

September 14, 2018

The 99th annual Pitt County American Legion Agricultural Fair is scheduled to be open Tuesday through Sept. 23 at the county fairgrounds, 3910 Martin Luther King Jr. Highway.

The event will feature a children’s barnyard, free shows and exhibits and nearly three dozen carnival rides from…

September 14, 2018

Don’t count your chickens before they hatch, especially during hurricane season.

Weather permitting, the Pitt County American Legion Agricultural Fair will open Tuesday. Canceled following Hurricane Floyd in 1999, the fair has managed to go on almost every year for nearly a century.



September 14, 2018

Editor’s note: The aftermath of Hurricane Florence could cause events to be canceled or postponed. Call for more information.


Pitt County Fair

The 99th annual Pitt County Fair will be held Tuesday-Sept. 23 at the Pitt County Fairgrounds, 3910 MLK Jr. Highway. The opening ceremony will…

September 14, 2018

Q During extended family get-togethers with my side of the family, there is one person who does 95 percent of the talking. When I ask someone else in the room a question about their lives, this person always jumps in and takes over the conversation again. This talker also never inquires about what…

Carolyn Hax

September 14, 2018


Pitt County Arts Council at Emerge will exhibit “The Black Light Project” and “Black Peace” through Sept. 28 in the Don Edwards and Harvey Wooten galleries. “The Black Light Project” is photographic documentary designed to highlight positive images of…

266 stories in Look. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 27
        Next Page»   Last Page»