I got the surprise of my life when people were complaining about a DR editorial. You mean the BYH column is not the...

A new way to look at the Civil War

1 of 3

D.G. Martin


Sunday, April 21, 2019

I surrender.

In wartime these words admit defeat and put the speaker in the custody of an adversary. They do not usually gain admiration.

Instead, we celebrate the advice popularly attributed to Winston Churchill: “Never give up. Never, never, never give up.”

We admire the single word reply, “Nuts!,” given by World War II Gen. Anthony McAuliffe responding to a German surrender demand during the Battle of the Bulge.

Sometimes, surrender is the right thing to do. And when it is necessary, it can be done properly and honorably. Or it can be done shamefully and dishonorably.

The differences are explained and illustrated in “Raising the White Flag: How Surrender Defined the American Civil War” by David Silkenat, a Duke grad with a PhD from UNC-Chapel Hill and now a senior lecturer of American History at the University of Edinburgh.

Silkenat gives his readers a new way to study the Civil War. Through the lens of surrender, the war begins at Fort Sumter and ends at Appomattox and the series of surrenders that followed, including Bennett Place in Durham.

Surrenders during the war were common. One of every four soldiers surrendered, either individually or as part of large capitulations.

At Sumter, the union commander, Major Robert Anderson, was deemed a hero after his surrender of the fort because he had held on until Confederate bombardments made it clear that further resistance would be futile.

On the other hand, at about the same time, when Major Isaac Lynde surrendered his command in New Mexico to a much smaller group of Confederates, he was branded a coward.

When the rebel commander at Fort Donelson on the Cumberland River in Tennessee near the Kentucky line capitulated to General U.S. (“Unconditional Surrender”) Grant in February 1862, many Confederates thought the surrender was disgraceful. “In this surrender, we have lost the chivalry and flower of our whole army,” one soldier said.

At Gettysburg surrenders of individuals and units on both sides were numerous. At the end of the battle, Gen. Robert E. Lee’s forces were burdened with thousands of Union captives. On the day following the battle, Lee’s attempt to negotiate a prisoner swap with victorious Union General Meade was fruitless. Meade knew that the prisoners would slow Lee’s retreat and enhance the Union forces’ efforts to harass the Confederates on their retreat to Virginia.

Before Gettysburg, generous parole and exchange policies on both sides could make surrender an attractive option for the ordinary soldier in a dangerous battlefield situation. Upon surrender, he was often treated reasonably well and promptly given freedom through an exchange or parole.

Silkenat suggests that if these generous policies had not been in force, the outcome at Gettysburg might have been quite different. He explains, “The frequency of the Confederate surrenders during Pickett’s Charge indicates that many rebel soldiers went into the assault believing that allowing themselves to be taken prisoner was preferable to assaulting an ensconced Union line.”

Had the attractive surrender option not been available, he continues, “it is within the realm of possibility that Confederate troops would have penetrated the Union line, allowing them to flank and rout the thin Federal defenses, taking and suffering heavy casualties. Unable to hold Cemetery Ridge, Union forces would have been forced to beat a hasty retreat, allowing Confederates to capture supplies and artillery and lodge a significant victory on Union soil.”

After Gettysburg, these surrender and parole options were virtually eliminated so that captured soldiers could look forward only to deadly confinement at places like Andersonville.

In his conclusion, Silkenat suggests that we “might come to see surrender not as a sign of weakness but as a hallmark of humanity.”

Even those who disagree with him on this point will welcome his treatment of surrender in his fresh, interesting, comprehensive, and challenging reassessment of Civil War history.

D.G. Martin is a a retired lawyer, politician and university administrator and is host of UNC-TV’s “North Carolina Bookwatch” 11 a.m. Sundays and 5 p.m. Tuesdays.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.


August 25, 2019

The other day I was doing a little nocturnal online shopping at one of favorite sites when I spotted some shoes I really liked.

My finger was hovering over the purchase button when a thought suddenly occurred to me. I went into the front hallway and opened a chest where I keep most of my shoes.…


August 25, 2019

What does a story told by a Jewish rabbi late last month at Chautauqua, N.Y., have to do with the North Carolina Board of Elections?

First a word about Chautauqua. Founded in 1874, it is the host to more than 100,000 visitors each summer. They participate in a series of lectures about religious,…


August 25, 2019

Badwater all starts as Goodwater.

Badwater Basin is the name of the lowest location in the United States, within Death Valley National Park. It is a saltpan valley 282 feet below sea level. If it wasn’t surrounded by mountains, it would flood Underwater.

It looks like a sea of ice in the hot…


August 23, 2019


Watermelon Festival

The 34th annual Winterville Watermelon Festival continues today-Sunday in downtown Winterville. The event will include carnival rides, a parade, a watermelon-eating contest and live music and entertainment. The Watermelon Jam concert, a ticketed event, will begin at 6 p.m.…


August 21, 2019

Q I recently was diagnosed with GERD (gastroesophageal reflux disease) and given medication. Are there any lifestyle changes I can make that will be helpful? I hate taking medicine. — GW, Greenville

A I asked Derek Schaap, a Brody medical student to answer your question. Here is what he wants…


August 21, 2019

When hurricanes or other natural disasters impact communities, it disrupts life in many ways. For those with chronic conditions, navigating these disruptions means preparing for the worst and having an excess of the life-saving medication they depend on.

Dr. Bryan Kitch, medical director of…

Prescriptions 2.jpg

August 18, 2019

I am quitting TV journalism. From now on, I'm getting my news from the papers. I have been thinking about it for a long time, but I finally decided when a friend of mine told me his story:

I was watching Nicole Wallace one afternoon as she preached about the imminent collapse of democracy as we…


August 16, 2019


Jazz fundraiser

The Churches Outreach Network will present an Evening of Jazz fundraiser from 6:30-9 p.m. today at Yankee Hall Plantation, 3332 Yankee Hall Road. The event, which will celebrate 11 years of service by CON, will include a three-course meal and a live jazz ensemble. Tickets are…


August 14, 2019

Q: I decided to try to use olive oil instead of vegetable oil. Standing in front of the olive oil section I couldn’t figure out what to buy. Can you help? KP, Farmville

A: You share the same dilemma with many of us. On a recent trip to Boston I went into a great market that had an entire…


August 11, 2019

Before she graduated from high school, Ghita Harris worked as a medical research assistant in the ECU School of Medicine, an opportunity that would have seemed to have put her on the fast track to becoming a physician. But more than two decades later, her journey has just begun.

The Greenville…

125 stories in Look. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 13
        Next Page»   Last Page»