Bless our hearts: We fought a civil war to end the Confederacy once and for all, and here we are... We fought a war to...

Tax changes benefit banker more than teller


Rob Christensen


Sunday, April 9, 2017

For most of the 20th century, North Carolina’s income tax operated on a simple principle — that the bank president should pay at a higher rate than the bank teller.

But the Republican legislature, in 2013, changed the tax laws so that everyone pays income taxes at the same rate — a modified flat tax.

Now the GOP-led legislature, in a move being pushed by Americans for Prosperity, an anti-tax group started by the Koch brothers, is considering enshrining the change in the state Constitution.

That would lock future legislatures into taxing the wealthy and working people at the same rate, unless they were to re-create a graduated income tax by establishing some lower rates.

Raising the standard deduction can also benefit lower-income taxpayers. The Republican legislature has done that — while also eliminating the earned-income tax credit for the working poor.

First, a little history.

North Carolina’s modern income tax has been in place since 1921. The 1919 legislature created the tax system with state income and corporate taxes funding state government, property taxes funding local governments, and a new Department of Revenue to administer and enforce the system. The changes were approved by the voters in a constitutional amendment passed in 1920.

Like the federal income tax, the state income tax was progressive, with rates ranging from 3.6 percent to 7 percent depending on how much a person earned. In later years, tax brackets were added for high-income earners with rates as high as 7.75 percent. The top rate was temporarily increased to 8.25 percent during the economic downturn at the beginning of this century.

The rationale behind a progressive income tax is that those who can afford to pay a greater share of their income should do so, and that democratic societies work better when there is not sharp income inequality and there is a vibrant middle class.

That was North Carolina’s political philosophy through 18 governors and 46 legislatures. That is also the way the U.S. tax code works, as well as most states.

But the progressive income tax never was popular with some of the wealthy, who resented paying higher rates. In addition, some critics argued it was bad policy, saying it deprived high earners of money even though they are responsible for most of the investing, risk-taking and entrepreneurship.

With the election of a conservative Republican legislature in 2010, the GOP lawmakers sought to rewrite the tax code. They essentially ditched the progressive income tax – which by then had three levels of 6 percent, 7 percent and 7.75 percent — and replaced it with a single rate of 5.499 percent.

Any loss of revenue was made up by the legislature by expanding the services covered by the sales tax — what economists call a regressive tax because the banker and his teller pay the same amount for whatever is bought, taking a greater portion of the teller’s income.

North Carolina last year was one of only eight states in the country with a flat income tax.

To effectively lock in the flat tax for future generations, Americans for Prosperity has launched an effort to pass a constitutional amendment that would cap the state income tax at 5.5 percent.

The state Senate voted March 14 on a constitutional amendment that if approved would go before voters in the November 2018 election. Senators approved the proposal 36-13, sending it to the House.

Americans for Prosperity has launched a statewide campaign, holding town-hall meetings and saying it will call more than 100,000 people across the state.

Donald Bryson, the state director of Americans for Prosperity, said the cap is needed to avoid “the failed tax-and-spend record of prior years.” 

Senate leader Phil Berger said the constitutional amendment is needed “to keep spendthrift politicians from returning to the days of high taxes and multibillion-dollar deficits.”

Here are some facts:

North Carolina was not a high tax state. During fiscal year 2012, the state-local tax burden in North Carolina was 9.8 percent, less than the U.S. average of 9.9 percent, according to the conservative-leaning Tax Foundation. That was before the Republican tax cuts.

Nor was the state a big spender. It ranked 45th in the country in state government per-capita spending in the years between 2001 and 2011, according to a 2013 study by the Tax Foundation.

As for the deficits, North Carolina’s state Constitution requires a balanced budget and the state is one of the few that has maintained a AAA bond rating from Wall Street bond houses.

The Republican leadership argues it is just giving voters a choice, in the form of a constitutional amendment, to permanently cap taxes.

The move comes at a time when numerous national studies have shown a growing income inequality nationally since the 1970s.

That is especially true in North Carolina, where the gap between high- and low-wage earners has grown over the past three decades from $10.44 per hour in 1980 to $15.85 per hour in 2011 in inflation-adjusted 2011 dollars, according to the N.C. Budget and Tax Center, part of the N.C. Justice Center that advocates for the underprivileged.

To put it another way, income for the top 1 percent of families in North Carolina grew 100 percent between 1979 and 2013, and for the other 99 percent of families it grew 12 percent, according to the liberal-leaning Center on Budget Policy Priorities.

That is certainly not the fault of the Republican legislature. But capping the income tax is likely to shift the tax burden permanently away from the wealthy and more to the middle class.

Rob Christensen has covered politics for The News & Observer of Raleigh for nearly four decades and is the author of The Paradox of Tar Heel Politics.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Op Ed

July 15, 2018 - 9 minutes ago

Vidant Health, like hospital systems around the nation, serves a critical role as a health care safety net, providing high-quality care to all patients, including those who are under or uninsured. 

According to the 2015 Small Area Income and Poverty Estimates, 28 of the 29 counties in the…

Brian Floyd

July 15, 2018 - 9 minutes ago

As a child in eastern China, Panshu Zhao worshipped the United States. "He read the Bible his parents gave him, watched Hollywood movies and studied the ideals of democracy," reports the Associated Press. "He jumped at the chance to attend graduate school at Texas A&M University."

In 2016, Zhao…

Steve and Cokie Roberts

July 15, 2018 - 9 minutes ago

As President Trump put Germany and other allies on notice for the harm they are doing to NATO with their failure to spend adequately on our common defense, Democrats in Washington came to Germany's defense. "President Trump's brazen insults and denigration of one of America's most steadfast allies,…


July 14, 2018

The Wall Street Journal

The U.S. economy continues to show strength in the wake of tax reform and deregulation, but the downside of robust growth is that Donald Trump thinks this means he can dabble at trade war with impunity. He ought to look at the signs that growth would be even stronger if not…

July 14, 2018

Judge Brett Kavanaugh's confirmation hearings to be a Supreme Court justice will take place in the shadow of the nomination of John Roberts to be chief justice 13 years ago.

Roberts was confirmed on a 78-22 vote in 2005. That's the most votes any justice has received for more than two decades. But…


July 14, 2018

Ever since that episode in Eden’s garden, the one where humans were enticed into eating the forbidden fruit, serpents have been considered the lowest of creatures. Most loathe the slithering reptile and use pejoratives to describe undesirable people as “lowlifes” or “snakes…

Tom Campbell.jpg

July 13, 2018

The Telegraph of London 

The extraordinary rescue of the 12 young footballers and their coach from a flooded cave network in Thailand is a magnificent story of human indomitability and ingenuity. The most eagerly followed rescue mission since 33 Chilean miners were trapped for weeks…

July 13, 2018

Late last month, the U.S. Supreme Court declined to decide North Carolina's gerrymandering case, Rucho v. Common Cause, and ordered further review by the lower court. This outcome followed earlier deferrals on redistricting cases out of Wisconsin and Maryland. Along with Justice Anthony Kennedy's…

Tom Ross

July 13, 2018

I'm confident that we can eventually repair the damage President Trump is doing to the nation. What he's doing to the world is another story.

As with much of his program, Trump's foreign policy is contradictory and ultimately self-defeating. He wants to lead — his voracious yet delicate ego…

Eugene Robinson

July 12, 2018

It's often been observed that special counsel Robert Mueller, assigned to investigate alleged Trump-Russia collusion in the 2016 presidential campaign, has yet to charge anyone with a crime involving Trump-Russia collusion in the 2016 presidential campaign.

The biggest of Mueller's indictments,…

Byron York.jpg
291 stories in Op Ed. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 30
        Next Page»   Last Page»