BYH to people who bash teachers. You literally would not last one class period at my school. I get cussed at, chairs...

Average teacher pay isn’t the right focus

john hood.jpg

John Hood


Monday, June 25, 2018

Whether North Carolina pays its public schoolteachers at a level close or equal to the national average is one of the most-debated issues in state politics. Alas, it doesn’t deserve to be.

The problem isn’t just that standard nationwide comparisons of teacher pay are both incomplete (they leave out the value and reliability of non-wage compensation such as pension benefits, for example) and of dubious relevance (the vast majority of teachers will never move across state lines for higher pay).

The fundamental problem with fixating on average teacher pay is that it bears little relationship to what we are really trying to accomplish: gains in student achievement and attainment.

By my count, about a hundred scholarly studies have been published since 1990 that tested the link between average teacher pay and educational outcomes. Most (57 percent) found no statistically significant relationship.

That really shouldn’t be surprising. While it is widely acknowledged that the quality of teaching is the single most important explanation for the value added by schools, simply giving across-the-board raises to all teachers — the excellent, the average, and the horrible — is unlikely to improve quality much.

It might modestly increase retention of excellent teachers, admittedly — but no more than, and probably far less than, it will increase retention of horrible ones. Long-term studies demonstrate that biggest effects on students occur in the “tails” of the teacher-quality curve. That is, exposure to an excellent teacher can be transformational. Exposure to a horrible teacher can be disastrous.

In reality, teacher pay is inherently differentiated. But in North Carolina, the practice until recently was to differentiate in ways that didn’t serve students well. We paid teachers more for every year of experience in the classroom, even though the gains from teacher experience were far, far larger in the early years of a teacher’s career than in later years. We paid teachers bonuses if they acquired graduate degrees, even though a clear preponderance of peer-reviewed studies — 85 percent, I’ve counted them — found no relationship to student performance.

In recent years, however, North Carolina has initiated a dramatic and promising change in how it pays teachers. Lawmakers raised the starting base salary to $35,000, up from $30,000, and the amount is higher in most places due to local supplements. Teachers can then gain very large raises during the early years of their careers, which serves to retain promising candidates and reward gains in effectiveness.

North Carolina then further differentiates pay according to performance. Some teachers are eligible for higher pay based on supervisor evaluations, gains in student achievement, or rates of student passage on Advance Placement and International Baccalaureate exams. Others have received thousands of dollars in raises as participants in a new pilot program, Advancing Teaching Roles, that redeploys teachers as either Multi-Classroom Leaders (who help boost the effectiveness of their colleagues) or Extended Impact Teachers (who reach more students throughout the school day).

Differentiating pay according to evaluations, student gains, enhanced duties, and working in hard-to-staff schools or subjects is both necessary and challenging. No state or district has yet mastered it, although there are important lessons to learn from programs currently in the field. In a new report for Georgetown University’s FutureEd program, Thomas Toch took a careful look at the District of Columbia’s evolving approach to hiring and paying teachers, concluding that the district “has given its students a far better chance than they had before.”

As for empirical research, a new paper by two Purdue University economists examined the effects of hundreds of pay-for-performance systems implemented statewide, district-wide, or at individual schools since 1986. Exposure to these programs, particularly in high-poverty schools, boosted student attainment and future outcomes such as employment and wage gains.

If student success is our goal, and it ought to be, then average pay is not the right policy priority. Instead, we should focus on attracting and retaining excellent teachers, providing incentives for improvement, and hastening consistently low performers out of the profession quickly — not giving across-the-board hikes. 

John Hood (@JohnHoodNC) is chairman of the John Locke Foundation and appears on “NC SPIN,” broadcast statewide Fridays at 7:30p and Sundays at 12:30p on UNC-TV.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Op Ed

May 23, 2019

From now on, the Trump-Russia affair — the investigation that dominated the first years of Donald Trump's presidency — will be divided into two parts: before and after the release of Robert Mueller's report. Before the special counsel's findings were made public last month, the…

Byron York.jpg

May 22, 2019

Presidential contenders are in a battle to out give one another. Sen. Elizabeth Warren proposes a whopping $50,000 per student college loan forgiveness. Sen. Bernie Sanders proposes free health care for all Americans plus illegal aliens. Most Democratic presidential candidates promise free stuff…

Walter Williams

May 21, 2019

Not that long ago, North Carolina Democrats had the "big tent" party — an eclectic group that shared common values but disagreed on many individual issues.

Moderate — sometimes even conservative — rural Democrats in the legislature worked alongside big city liberals. The moderates…

Colin Campbell

May 21, 2019

Later this week, North Carolina will renew its partnership with a little-known country that's been bringing out the best in our state's people for more than two decades.

North Carolina's National Guard has been helping the country's defense forces throughout this time. Librarians from Wilmington…

David Jarmul

May 20, 2019

North Carolina appropriates less taxpayer money to state colleges and universities in real terms than it did before the onset of the Great Recession. Tuition has risen markedly and now accounts for a larger share of total revenue. But our state remains one of the most generous in the country when…

john hood.jpg

May 20, 2019

How many people have the ability to manipulate the stock market? One, and this isn’t a trick question. We’re watching how President Trump’s statements about slapping tariffs on China one day, or the great headway he’s making on a China trade deal the next day can tank the…


May 19, 2019

The Washington Post

The prime minister of New Zealand, Jacinda Ardern, has said she does not think anyone would argue that the perpetrator of the Christchurch massacre should have been able to livestream mass murder. Maybe that question elicits something close to unanimity — but in trying to…

May 19, 2019

Facebook co-founder Chris Hughes, adding his voice to calls to "break up" the social media giant, calls it a "powerful monopoly, eclipsing all of its rivals and erasing competition." In recent years, we've seen similar claims, and heard demands for similar remedies, aimed at Google, Amazon, and…


May 19, 2019

With a competent president in the White House, the escalating confrontation with Iran would not rise to the level of crisis. With President Trump calling the shots, we should be afraid. Very afraid.

A rational president, of course, would not have abandoned the landmark deal that halted Iran's…

Eugene Robinson

May 18, 2019

I’ve been watching the emerging election for North Carolina’s Senate seat and wonder if we are seeing symptoms of a larger trend. Our traditional tribalism — Republicans and Democrats — has morphed into contentious sub-tribes within each party. Instead of a sure re-…

Tom Campbell.jpg
247 stories in Op Ed. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 25
        Next Page»   Last Page»