BYH to folks that don’t move over or get out of the way for emergency vehicles. One day it might be your relative they...

No done deals in midterms

Margaret Sullivan

Margaret Sullivan


Wednesday, October 17, 2018

After the roller-coaster ride of 2016's election night, have journalists and political junkies learned not to let conventional wisdom substitute for hard knowledge?

Nate Silver, the closest thing there is to a celebrity in the arcane field of statistical journalism, is not wildly optimistic about that.

"Media understanding about probability, margin of error and uncertainty is very poor," Silver said Monday afternoon when I stopped by the Manhattan office of his fivethirtyeight.com.

"That led them to be more surprised than they should have been," he said, based on the quite accurate polling numbers that were available.

Now that we're three weeks away from the midterm elections, Silver is seeing some of the same tendencies in media coverage and social-media chatter that plagued 2016's coverage.

Take the Senate challenge to Republican incumbent Ted Cruz of Texas by Beto O'Rourke, for instance.

When the polls had O'Rourke's chances of upsetting Cruz at a 35 percent probability, the media chatter had it as almost a toss-up. Now that those chances have dropped to about 25 percent, the prevailing narrative has downgraded O'Rourke almost to dead-man-walking status.

"That's not a night-and-day change, but that's how it's being talked about," Silver said. Which leads to his worry about coverage over the next few weeks, and particularly in the days leading up to Nov. 6.

"I get nervous about how people overstate things" he told me. That, for example, it's "all but inevitable" that Democrats will win control of the House of Representatives or that there's really no way Republicans will lose the Senate.

"Saying it's all but inevitable should signal it's at 98 percent, not 80 percent," which is the reality at the moment, he said.

While it's quite probable — and has become slightly more likely — that we'll see a split decision in Congress, there's a solid chance it doesn't go that way.

There's actually a 40 percent chance that both houses of Congress will end up in the hands of one party, Silver said. That's because, in each case, there's about a one in five chance that the less likely outcome will happen: That Republicans will retain the House or that Democrats will win the Senate.

Silver has had his own ups and downs with predicting election outcomes, including during 2016. He infamously stated during the primary that Trump's candidacy was not to be taken seriously. When proved wrong, he followed up with a thorough self-examination, published on his site, that he was thinking too much like a political journalist and not enough like a statistician.

On the plus side, his final-days projections were better than most: He gave Hillary Clinton roughly a 7 in 10 chance of winning, with Trump at about 3 in 10. And he doesn't fault the polls, which were quite accurate, he said:

"There are lots of reasons the outcome was surprising, but the polls were the least of it."

Midterm elections present their own predictive challenges: There's a lot less data, fewer polls to analyze, in states and regions than in a national election.

So while lots of people think they know exactly what's going to happen — and are more than willing to hold forth as if they're infallible — there's still a lot of uncertainty, given the numbers.

"People should not be that surprised by a Democratic Senate or a Republican House," Silver told me. "We're in dangerous territory from a predictive/assumption standpoint."

A four-in-five chance may sound like a done deal, but it simply isn't.

But, I asked, didn't the media learn these lessons, once and for all, two years ago?

"People do learn things the hard way," he acknowledged, and there was no harder way than election night 2016. So he's observing more necessary caution this time around.

Whether that caution will last into Election Day itself is another equation altogether.

That doesn't mean that the polls are useless or that nobody knows anything.

It just means that probability is one thing — and inevitability is quite another.

Margaret Sullivan is The Washington Post’s media columnist. Previously, she was the New York Times public editor, and the chief editor of the Buffalo News.


Humans of Greenville


Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Op Ed

November 15, 2018

When French President Emmanuel Macron denounced populist nationalism this week and called on world leaders to support institutions such as the United Nations that defend "the common good of the world," liberal elites cheered. The speech was seen as a rebuke of President Trump, whose opposition to…


November 15, 2018

The 2018 election is finally and mercifully over and now is no time for progressives to rest on their laurels. Having taken some promising initial steps in the struggle to overcome Trumpism and build a better, fairer, freer and more sustainable nation and planet, now is the time for caring and…

Rob Schofield

November 15, 2018

Bad news for North Carolina is official: Amazon decided to split its east coast headquarters between two cities — and neither one is in our state. New York City and Alexandria, Va., will split the estimated 50,000 jobs and $5 billion in investment from the Seattle company’s…

Mark Johnson

November 14, 2018

The Washington Post

One of American elections' biggest vulnerabilities can be found in one of the most obvious places: the voting machines themselves. The country's voting infrastructure may not have been tampered with this time around, but experts say outdated systems and an overreliance on…

November 14, 2018

When Democrats took control of the House in Tuesday's midterm elections, two things were certain: President Trump's remaining legislative agenda is dead, and the chamber's Judiciary Committee is ready to combat any White House attempt to meddle in or obstruct special counsel Robert S. Mueller's…


November 14, 2018

According to a recent report in The New York Times, Health and Human Services Department officials have been circulating a proposal to define sex. Their memo says, "Sex means a person's status as male or female based on immutable biological traits identifiable by or before birth."

They add, "The…

Walter Williams

November 13, 2018

Jennifer Rubin, The Washington Post

"Saturday Night Live" comedian Pete Davidson got reamed for making a tasteless joke a week ago Saturday about Dan Crenshaw, a former Navy SEAL who lost his eye in combat in Afghanistan. Days later, Texans elected Crenshaw, a Republican, to Congress. On…

November 13, 2018

Democrats achieved significant victories this year in the “inner suburbs” of Charlotte, Raleigh, Greensboro, and North Carolina’s other major cities — tossing out GOP incumbents in the General Assembly, county commissions, and other offices.

Although Republicans did better…

john hood.jpg

November 13, 2018

North Carolina's urban-rural divide grew to a chasm in this month's election — at least in the state legislature.

Republicans suffered huge losses in urban counties, likely leaving the party with only two or three representatives from the two biggest counties: Wake and Mecklenburg. But…

Colin Campbell

November 12, 2018

The Telegraph of London, England

Although the EU, including Britain, is sticking to the nuclear deal unilaterally repudiated by President Trump, without America’s backing it is pretty much a dead duck. Since European companies that continue trading with Iran risk being hit by secondary U.S.…

303 stories in Op Ed. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 31
        Next Page»   Last Page»