Loading...
BYH: To the City of Greenville, NC. Your town is a boring town, filled with drunks(bars), nothing else to do. Crimes in...

Give obsolete aircraft carriers burial at sea

Knapp

Thomas Knapp

Loading…

Monday, March 4, 2019

The U.S. Department of Defense wants to retire an old aircraft carrier early while building two new ones, as well as adding other goodies to their shopping list.

Surprise, surprise — politicians from states with the shipyards and naval bases that employ their constituents want to keep the old carrier and build the new ones.

America and Americans would be better off if Congress retired the USS Harry S. Truman, nixed the DoD request for two new Ford-class carriers, and worked up plans for an orderly retirement of several more carriers too. The U.S. Navy's surface warfare ship complement is too large, too expensive, and too oriented toward fighting previous wars to serve any rational "defense" purpose.

The Navy operates 20 of the world's 41 active aircraft carriers, including 11 flat-top "super-carriers," each Carrier Strike Group disposing of more firepower than most countries' entire militaries. There's precisely zero danger of the U.S. falling into a flat-top "carrier gap," even if that was something to be avoided. And it isn't.

World War II, in which carriers replaced battleships as the central factor in naval warfare, ended three quarters of a century ago. Carriers as such may not be entirely passé, but 1,000-foot "super-carriers" like the existing Nimitz-class and the forthcoming Ford-class are.

If carriers have a future, it's in Short Take-Off But Arrested Recovery, or STOBAR, ships. They're smaller, cheaper, less vulnerable, and over the last 75 years aircraft have been developed that don't need a thousand feet of deck to take off from or land on.

The notional lifespan of a Nimitz-class aircraft carrier is 50 years, but none are quite that old. The USS Nimitz's keel was laid 50 years ago last June, but the ship wasn't finished, commissioned, and deployed until the mid-1970s. it's undergone 19 reduced availability periods, including two "complex" overhauls, since then; it's in the middle of a state of "planned incremental availability" at the moment.

The reasons these old ships remain in service (and new ones designed on the same general concept are under construction) aren't defensive, or even military, in nature. They're about money. Money for "defense" contractors, money for the politicians they contribute to and paychecks for the employees who vote for those politicians.

Unfortunately, once that money's spent and the ships and weapons make it into active service, the temptation to use them tends to overwhelm good sense, dragging America into non-defensive wars neither it nor the world around it needs.

The U.S. government's "defense" budget is the single largest discretionary area of federal spending. It's an aging hippie in dire need of a clean shave and a buzz cut. There's no better place to start trimming than the U.S. Navy's carriers and their supporting ships and infrastructure.

Thomas L. Knapp is director and senior news analyst at the William Lloyd Garrison Center for Libertarian Advocacy Journalism (thegarrisoncenter.org). He lives and works in north central Florida.

 

Loading…

Humans of Greenville

@HumansofGville

Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Op Ed

March 24, 2019

The San Diego Union-Tribune

President Donald Trump’s plan to divert $6.6 billion from the Pentagon and the Treasury Department to help pay for the construction of a border wall is a frontal assault on the constitutional provision that gives Congress the authority to appropriate public funds.…

March 24, 2019

Bill Friday, the founding president of what is now the 17-campus University of North Carolina, presided from 1956 until his retirement in 1986 over a spectacular period of growth — and yes, glory — for an institution that has been a source of pride for millions of North Carolinians who…

5Bowles.jpg

March 24, 2019

As a member of the Board of Trustees of the North Carolina State Health Plan, I want to give a board-member perspective on some of the issues surrounding our proposed changes to medical provider reimbursements.

The board has devoted many hours to this problem and fully supports Treasurer Dale…

Peter Robie

March 23, 2019

Nancy McFarlane is my mayor. She has led Raleigh through explosive growth, including a new train station, the purchase of Dix Park, promotion of Raleigh as an arts scene and tourist destination and recognition on many “best of” lists. Why is she stepping down?

It’s not because of…

021117campbell

March 23, 2019

The sleeper issue this election cycle could be the Electoral College and the unfairness it has come to represent. The fix would require a constitutional amendment mandating a federally-regulated popular vote that includes a runoff election if necessary to establish a majority-vote winner. In other…

douglascohn.jpg

March 22, 2019

Poor Felicity Huffman is being raked over the coals for paying a lousy $15,000 to get her daughter extra time to take the SAT.

Jared Kushner's father paid $2.5 million to get him into Harvard — and arranged for two of his beneficiary politicians, Sens. Ted Kennedy and Frank Lautenberg, to…

AnnCoulter

March 21, 2019

The state treasurer and the N.C. Healthcare Association can't reach consensus over how to pay for health insurance for state employees. The governor and some legislative leaders are advocating Medicaid expansion to cover an additional 600,000 people.

The debate, proposals, and arguments have…

BeckyGray

March 20, 2019

According to CNN Business, "Facebook, YouTube and Twitter struggle to deal with New Zealand shooting video."

"Deal with" is code for "censor on demand by governments and activist organizations who oppose public access to information that hasn't first been thoroughly vetted for conformity to their…

Knapp

March 19, 2019

It was one of the deadliest years in the history of North Carolina’s prison system. Five prison employees were killed in two incidents at state prisons in 2017. Given the way our prisons were staffed and the guards were trained and equipped, we should have seen it coming.

The two incidents…

March 19, 2019

"America is addicted to political contempt."

I'm not sure I've ever read a more accurate diagnosis of what we're looking at in the United States right now.

I'm quoting from a new book by Arthur C. Brooks, "Love Your Enemies: How Decent People Can Save America From the Culture of Contempt." I had…

kathrynlopez
283 stories in Op Ed. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 29
        Next Page»   Last Page»