Loading...
'BYH' to the GOP, working on their new motto, "We don't mind if a man tries to rape you, we only care if you don't want...

Roe vs. Wade is about more than abortion

Nancy Northup

Nancy Northup

Loading…

Tuesday, July 10, 2018

On Monday, President Donald Trump is expected to announce his nominee to replace Justice Anthony Kennedy on the Supreme Court. Given the president's promise to appoint justices who would overturn Roe v. Wade, it's widely understood that his nominee will pose a clear danger to women's reproductive rights. What most don't realize is that everyone's personal-liberty rights are on the line.

The constitutional framework of Roe is about far more than abortion. It's about rearing our children without unwarranted government interference. It's about choosing whom we want to marry. It's about deciding with whom we want to create a home. It's about the right to use contraception. It's about what the Supreme Court in Planned Parenthood v. Caseyexplained is the "promise of the Constitution that there is a realm of personal liberty which the government may not enter."

This guarantee of individual liberty is bound together through decades of accumulated legal precedent. Within the interconnected framework of our rights, Roeis a load-bearing element. Knock it down, and the structure falls.

Roe is 45 years old. It resides in the middle of nearly a century of jurisprudence reaching backward and forward in time: expanding on the liberty protections that came before it and laying the groundwork for recognition of important future rights.

In deciding Roe, the court looked to cases in the 1920s on the right of parents to educate their children according to their values and ideas, and the justices drew a line to landmark decisions affirming the right to use contraception and, in 1967's Loving v. Virginia, the right to marry someone of a different race.

That line led to the conclusion, enshrined in Roe and elaborated on in Casey, that liberty cannot exist if we are not free to make decisions about our lives, bodies and health free from government interference.

Just as Roe rested on past liberty decisions, it became the basis for future ones — including outside the area of women's reproductive rights. The court cited Roe and Casey's reasoning in a broad range of subsequent cases. Those include landmark decisions protecting liberty rights, as in Lawrence v. Texas (2003), which held that the government cannot criminalize intimate sexual conduct between same-sex partners, and Obergefell v. Hodges (2015), guaranteeing same-sex couples the right to marry.

This line of precedent protects us all, and a post-Kennedy Supreme Court could not sever it without threatening to destroy our "realm of personal liberty."

Overturn Roe, and that protected realm vanishes.

The short-term impact would bring a drastic reduction in access to reproductive health care for millions of women. If Roe fell tomorrow, as many as 23 states could immediately ban abortion. As in the days before Roe, the harm would fall hardest on young and low-income women, women of color and anyone unable to travel out of state to seek access to abortion care that was once available closer to home.

The long-term harm would not be limited to women who need abortion care. Invite the government to exert control over a woman's body, and invite tyranny over our most intimate and personal life decisions.

That's why it's time to stop talking about Roe as a stand-alone case. The Supreme Court can't just negate a woman's right to abortion without unraveling protections for all. You can have either the president's promise about overturning Roe or the Constitution's promise of a realm of personal liberty. You can't have both.

Nancy Northup is president and chief executive of the Center for Reproductive Rights.

Loading…

Humans of Greenville

@HumansofGville

Local photographer Joe Pellegrino explores Greenville to create a photographic census of its people.

Opinion

September 22, 2018

Sharon and I took our first college student out for a late dinner this week after some computer shopping. An amazingly knowledgeable young man in the computer store hooked us up with what he considered the optimal choice in a laptop for engineering majors.

I keep reassuring Carly that she is free…

Cube.jpg

September 22, 2018

Bless your heart to the team at WNCT-Channel 9 TV who covered the details of Hurricane Florence from Wednesday through Sunday. Their report covered more than 50 hours, keeping the television audience up to date. Dontae Jones, David Sawyer, Jerry Jackson and Maria Satira, along with the remote…

September 22, 2018

Bloomberg Opinion

President Donald Trump's planned nomination of Nellie Liang to the Federal Reserve's Board of Governors, which oversees everything from interest-rate policy to financial stability, is a little surprising. She's admirably well-qualified and in every way a good choice.

Trump hasn't…

September 22, 2018

On Sept. 13, someone wrote in Bless Your Heart that 8 million Jehovah's Witnesses don't salute the flag and 200,000 Amish do not stand for the national anthem, yet one black man kneels respectfully and all hell breaks loose.

I blame the media. They are the ones who showed the black man…

September 22, 2018

Many articles over the past year have shocked me to my core. One issue, however, is by far the most impactful. In August, over 300 priests were accused of adolescent sexual abuse by more than 1,000 victims throughout Pennsylvania. The astonishing number of cases is a concern that needs to be…

September 22, 2018

An oft-used, if hackneyed, axiom is: Close only counts in horseshoes and hand grenades. Applied to politics, it means that if you lose a special election, don't try again in the general.

Danny O'Connor says he's going to defy that conventional wisdom. Last month, the 32 year-old Democrat barely…

albert hunt

September 22, 2018

There was the thought of leaping onto a desk and screaming “you tell ‘em” when a three-judge federal panel delivered a stern comeuppance for lawyers representing the General Assembly in the ongoing congressional redistricting case.

In their order last week to stay action of their…

Redistricting North Carolina

September 22, 2018

It happened once again with Hurricane Florence. Whenever North Carolina is in crisis — such as with storms or other catastrophes — we collectively rise to the occasion. Politics, rivalries and past animosities disappear, and we witness the best of humanity.

We have to commend state…

Tom Campbell.jpg

September 21, 2018

The citizens of Grifton have continued since Hurricane Floyd to go without power for several days after a hurricane due to Duke Energy not addressing the issue with its substation on Harvey Rouse Road.

This substation floods every time a storm hits our area because of an canal running beside the…

September 21, 2018

Where is James Baker when we need him?

The political maneuvering required to get Judge Brett Kavanaugh confirmed to the Supreme Court is probably the most important and consequential since the Florida recount in 2000, so deftly navigated by the old Republican hand Baker on behalf of George W. Bush.…

EdRogers
706 stories in Opinion. Viewing 1 through 10.
«First Page   «Previous Page        
Page 1 of 71
        Next Page»   Last Page»